Cracking the 'Blade Code' – Exploring the Balance Between Mass Transfer and Shear in Cell Factories

In the microscopic world of biopharmaceuticals,Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cellsare the key platform for producing antibody drugs, with nearly 90% of global antibody drugs originating from this precise 'cell factory.' As demands for production capacity and efficiency increase, achieving high-density cell culture in bioreactors while maintaining efficient production has become a significant challenge for the industry. The core difficulty lies in balancing two needs: enhancing mass transfer to supply sufficient oxygen and nutrients to the cells, while controlling shear forces to avoid mechanical damage that could stress or even kill the cells.

Impeller, as a key component in reactor flow field design, its structure directly determines the achievement of the aforementioned balance. Based on scientific impeller design methods, Morimatsu systematically studied the performance of different impellers in high-density cultures.

CHO cells lack the protection of a cell wall and are extremely sensitive to shear stress. Excessive shear stress can directly damage the cell membrane, leading to cell death. Even lower sub-lethal shear stress can inhibit cell growth and reduce drug production efficiency.

In high-density cultures, the cell count can reach hundreds of millions per milliliter, and their oxygen consumption increases exponentially. This requires that the reactor must achieve uniform and efficient oxygen delivery internally, as hypoxia in any corner could lead to metabolic disorders in the cells.

What complicates matters further is that the viscosity of cell suspensions at high densities is not fixed, but exhibits shear-thinning characteristics—thick when at rest and thinning upon agitation. This key physical property fundamentally alters the fluid dynamics within the reactor, posing challenges to traditional design theories.

Senson uses advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation technology to systematically evaluate five commonly used axial flow blades under the same operating conditions, including the three-narrow blade hydrofoil, skewed blade, three-wide blade hydrofoil, separated blade, and elephant ear blade.

The fluid circulation inside the reactor is like a city’s traffic system—it must be both strongly flowing and fully covered, avoiding stagnant 'dead zones' where material exchange halts. Simulation results show that wide impellers have a significant advantage in driving overall circulation.

Narrow impellers can only drive the fluid in the middle and lower parts of the reactor, with near-zero flow velocity near the liquid surface, easily forming dead zones. In contrast, wide impellers such as elephant-ear impellers generate strong axial pumping forces, creating a uniform large-scale circulation throughout the reactor, ensuring every cell is involved.

Cell respiration depends on oxygen supply through bubble aeration. Whether the bubbles can be evenly dispersed and delivered to every corner directly determines the uniformity of dissolved oxygen within the reactor, which in turn affects whether cells have a suitable microenvironment for growth and production.

Wide impellers, thanks to their larger blade area and stronger liquid circulation, again outperform in gas-phase dispersion. Among them, the elephant-ear impeller performs the best—it effectively 'binds' and disperses bubbles in the impeller zone, preventing them from escaping quickly along the wall without full utilization, thus achieving a more uniform dissolved oxygen environment within the reactor.

The core metric of mass transfer efficiency is the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient (kLa), which measures the rate at which oxygen transfers from bubbles to liquid. The results show that the kLa values for pitched-blade and elephant-ear impellers are the highest.

The advantage of the elephant-ear impeller lies not only in its superior numerical performance but also in achieving nearly 'uniform global mass transfer' due to its excellent gas-phase dispersion uniformity. This means that as cells move within the reactor, the dissolved oxygen concentration in their microenvironment remains stable, avoiding imbalances and ensuring CHO cells stay in a suitable microenvironment for production.

This is the final and most critical test. The maximum shear forces generated by all impellers are concentrated at the blade tips, exceeding the tolerance limits of the cells, but these high-risk areas account for a very small proportion. The true difference lies in the spatiotemporal distribution of shear forces experienced by cells as they travel through the reactor. By randomly tracking the trajectories of individual cells, it was found that in reactors equipped with elephant-ear impellers, the frequency and duration of cells encountering high-intensity shear forces (>2Pa, sub-lethal range) were significantly lower than with other impellers.

This indicates that the elephant-ear impeller creates a more stable and gentle mechanical microenvironment for the cells, greatly reducing the risk of accumulated stress injuries caused by frequent 'damage,' perfectly aligning with the shear-sensitive characteristics of CHO cells.

Based on the above analysis across four dimensions,Elephant Ear ImpellerWith its unique broad arc-shaped blade design, it achieves the optimal balance inenhancing mass transferandcontrolling shear forcethis core contradiction:

1 Through strong circulation and uniform gas dispersion, it ensures precise delivery of nutrients and oxygen.

2 By forming an appropriate flow field structure, it minimizes mechanical stress on cells.

This is also the underlying logic behind why Morimatsu glass bioreactors chose the Elephant Ear Impeller as a core technology—using scientific, quantifiable design to truly understand cell needs, providing a solid and reliable equipment foundation for the industrial success of high-density culture processes.

Against the backdrop of biopharmaceuticals moving towards enhanced efficiency, the success of processes hinges on a deep understanding of fundamental science and the seamless integration of cutting-edge engineering technologies. Through scientific tools like CFD simulation, Morimatsu has upgraded traditional 'experience-driven' approaches to 'data and model-driven' ones, precisely deciphering the code of impellers. In the future, with the deep integration of artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies, the design of bioreactors will become more intelligent and refined. Morimatsu will continue to focus on this area, using more advanced scientific equipment to help global pharmaceutical companies break through production capacity bottlenecks, steadily entering the fast lane of efficient biopharmaceutical production, bringing more high-quality biologics to patients.

[1] Botao Zhang, Xinran Zhang, Qingyuan Ran, Weijian Zhang, Gance Dai, Liang Zhao, Qian Ye, Wen-Song Tan. Rheology of CHO Cell Suspensions and Its Effects on High‐Density Cultivation Process and Bioreactor Design [J]. Biotechnology Journal. 2025, 20(3): e70003.

[2] Botao Zhang, Qingyuan Ran, Gance Dai, Qian Ye, Liang Zhao, Wen-Song Tan. Comparison of Perfusion Culture Performance in Orbitally Shaken Bioreactors and Stirred Tank Bioreactors: A Spatiotemporal Dynamic Analysis of Shear Stress and Mass Transfer Based on Suspension Rheology [J]. Processes. 2025, 13(4): 955.

[3] Walsh G, Walsh E. Biopharmaceutical benchmarks 2022[J]. Nature Biotechnology, 2022, 40(12): 1722-1760.

[4] Neunstoecklin B, Stettler M, Solacroup T, et al. Determination of the maximum operating range of hydrodynamic stress in mammalian cell culture[J]. Journal of Biotechnology, 2015, 194: 100-109.

[5] Srom O, Travnikova V, Wutz J, et al. Characterization of hydrodynamic stress in ambr250® bioreactor system and its impact on mammalian cell culture[J]. Biochemical Engineering Journal, 2022, 177.

[6] Zakrzewski R, Lee K, Lye G J. Development of a miniature bioreactor model to study the impact of pH and DOT fluctuations on CHO cell culture performance as a tool to understanding heterogeneity effects at large-scale[J]. Biotechnology Progress, 2022, 38(4).